Once the 90s hit, 11 years after Domino's implemented their guarantee, lawsuits started coming to light of people who were killed or injured by Domino's drivers trying to make their deadline. In 1992, the company had to pay $2.8 million to the family of Susan Noonan, a woman whose van was struck by a Domino's driver. Noonan died as a result of the accident, and her three sons, plus a friend,s were injured in the accident as well. Domino's maintains that poor road and weather conditions were the cause of the accident, not their delivery time requirements.
The lawsuit that finally shut down the guarantee, however, was in 1993 when Domino's was forced to pay $79 million to a St. Louis woman who was struck and permanently injured by one of their drivers. The woman says the driver ran a red light and hit her car, causing a spinal cord injury. The jury awarded the woman $750,000 in actual damages, and $78 million in punitive damages.
Tom Monaghan made the decision to pull the guarantee after public perception that Domino's is encouraging their employees to drive dangerously to avoid having to give away free pizza.
"I believe we are the safest delivery company in the world. But there continues to be a perception ... that the guarantee is unsafe. We got that message loud and clear," Monaghan said after the verdict.
"The risk [of even higher jury awards] becomes greater ... and they would be exposing themselves to additional suits," said corporate lawyer Kathleen Collins, referring to what could happen if Domino's chose not to revoke the 30 minutes or less guarantee.
The new policy became to offer $3 refunds if pizzas were late, which one franchiser said costs him $300,000 a year. Frank Meeks owned 53 Domino's in the Maryland, Virginia, and the District and he chose not to abide by the new policy.
"If I thought for one minute it was unsafe, I would drop it," he said of the 30-minute guarantee. "But we've never had a serious accident in Washington. We've had some fender benders. I'm a renegade. I'm not going to do it."
The only countries to continue with the 30 minutes or less guarantee are India and South Korea, thought many people would think otherwise.
Did you know there was no such thing as a "30 minutes or less" guarantee anymore? Let us know!