Did You Know | Holidays | Dessert | Food

You Won't Be Able To Take Your Eyes Off These Creepy Halloween Treats


Print Recipe

These cookies bring a whole new meaning to the phrase 'eye candy'. Your friends and family won't believe their eyes when they see these spooky sweet treats! Oreo Eyeballs look just like real eyes, but they taste oh-so-yummy (not AT ALL like an actual eye!) and are a cinch to make. Serve them up at your Halloween parties and watch as they disappear in the blink of an eye!


  • Package of Oreos
  • Blue and green decorating gel (we used sparkle gel but regular will work too)
  • Red gel food coloring
  • Brown/black M&Ms or Reese's Pieces
  • Toothpicks or small paintbrush


Remove one of the chocolate cookie wafers from your Oreos.


Add a dollop of blue or green decorating gel to the center of each piece of white Oreo icing.


Place one M&M or Reese's Pieces in the center of your green or blue icing blob.


Using a toothpick, or a small paintbrush, paint red veins using red gel icing on the white icing of each Oreo.


Your eyeballs are now ready to eat...if you dare!

Do you know someone who loves spooky treats? Make sure to share this recipe with them!

Watch our video below to see how to make these creepy Oreo Eyeballs. Enjoy!

Ashley has been with Shared for more than three years. She's a food, puppy and travel lover.